Excitement Meets Unexpected Criticism (Image Credits: Cdn01.justjared.com)
Actress Sarah Drew navigated a wave of online criticism after celebrating the renewal of her Hallmark series just one day following the death of her former Grey’s Anatomy co-star Eric Dane.[1][2]
Excitement Meets Unexpected Criticism
On February 20, 2026, Drew shared a lively Instagram Reel alongside co-star Peter Mooney, hugging and cheering over the news that Mistletoe Murders had been picked up for a third season. The caption read, “Merry merry MISTLETOE MURDERS SEASON 3 babyyyyyyy!!! CANNOT WAIT!!!” Fans and fellow Hallmark stars flooded the comments with enthusiasm.[3][4]
However, one commenter labeled the post “tone deaf,” a remark that appeared to reference Eric Dane’s passing the previous day. Dane, known for his role as Dr. Mark Sloan on Grey’s Anatomy, had died at age 53 after battling amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).[5] The timing struck a chord amid broader reports of global unrest.
Drew’s Graceful and Nuanced Response
Drew replied directly to the critic, offering a measured yet passionate defense. She wrote, “I imagine this comment is in reference to the news about Eric Dane, or the fall of our democracy, or people getting kidnapped and killed in the streets, or the atrocities of the Epstein files, or the deeply corrupt administration we are living under- or any of the other truly heartbreaking things that are happening at the same time- all the time.”[1][2]
She continued, “I just want to encourage you- that many things can be true at the same time. I can grieve one thing and celebrate another. I can work and I can mother. I’d ask you to offer a little bit of grace. We have to find our joy where it comes because joy is resistance. And this show and this community brings me so much joy, so I will celebrate that… while also grieving all of the other things I’ve mentioned.” Her words highlighted the complexity of processing personal milestones alongside public tragedies.
Fans Rally in Support
The response resonated widely, prompting an outpouring of support from followers. One fan called it “the perfect response,” while another noted, “There’s terrible, bad, horrible news at every turn… what keeps us all going through sad times is life.”[2]
Supporters praised her grace under pressure. Comments included affirmations like “Always so graceful” and defenses against unrealistic expectations placed on celebrities. Here are some key reactions:
- “Should she ONLY post about bad things? And not what she has going on as an actor which is her own livelihood?”
- “Celebrate your joys. You worked hard for it!”
- “Loss is inevitable but… the ability to celebrate the joys.”
The Rise of Mistletoe Murders
Mistletoe Murders stars Drew as Emily Lane, a Christmas store owner in Fletcher’s Grove who solves local mysteries. The series, now renewed for Season 3, ends its second season on a cliffhanger: Emily’s ex, Aaron, arrives unexpectedly at her door amid revelations of her past in intelligence.[4]
Drew, an executive producer, expressed thrill about returning. Production begins later in 2026, with episodes slated for Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas lineup. Co-star Peter Mooney echoed the excitement for the cast and crew reunion in Toronto.
Key Takeaways
- Sarah Drew balanced celebration and grief in her response to criticism.
- Mistletoe Murders Season 3 promises to resolve a major cliffhanger.
- Fans emphasized the importance of joy amid ongoing world challenges.
Sarah Drew’s exchange underscores a timeless tension in the public eye: the right to personal joy during collective sorrow. Her call for grace offers a reminder that resilience often lies in embracing both. What do you think about finding joy in tough times? Tell us in the comments.
